Three serious mistakes by Cafcass

Summary 106 |

Cafcass wrongly told a man with dyslexia that he could not have anyone with him at interview, did not check information before putting it in a report and did not recognise or apologise for its mistakes.


What happened

Cafcass did not interview Mr S before writing a report to the court. It also put information in its report without any evidence to show that it had asked Mr S or his daughter about it. Cafcass failed to recognise its mistakes, which forced Mr S to complain to us.

What we found

Cafcass made three mistakes: it failed to realise that Mr S's father could have been at his interview; it put information in its report about Mr S's parents sharing his daughter's care without consulting him or his daughter and without making sure that this information was correct; and it failed to recognise or apologise for its mistakes throughout the complaints process.

Cafcass's mistakes made Mr S feel unfairly treated and that he had not been given a reasonable opportunity to put his point across.

The mistakes also caused Mr S frustration by failing to resolve matters through the complaints process.

Putting it right

Cafcass apologised to Mr S and paid him £750. It also wrote to the court so that our findings are on record; took steps to make sure its staff know that people are allowed to have someone with them at interview; and took steps to make sure it handles complaints in line with its own processes and that complainants with a genuine grievance are not labelled as 'vexatious'.

Health or Parliamentary
Parliamentary
Organisations we investigated

Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service (Cafcass)

Location

UK

Complainants' concerns ?

Did not involve complainant adequately in the process

Result

Apology

Compensation for non-financial loss

Recommendation to change policy or procedure

Taking steps to put things right